A line of people waits down the hall outside the Barbara M. Donnellan Auditorium at the Central Library on Saturday, Nov. 14 for a taste from some of Arlington’s best bakers. Small white cups, each with a tiny wooden spoon, are lined up on tables crisscrossed across the room. The crowd is tightly packed around the tables as hands attempt to squeeze through an open space to grab a bite and pick up a recipe sheet nearby.
What to do? To choose a bite of whoopie pie, key lime pie, peanut butter sandwich cookie, birthday brownies or kardemummabullar bun? Each participant was asked to try two samples, vote and then leave space for the next in line who were waiting patiently to enter the room.
Each entry had a story. Just inside the entrance Jamie Gelsond was cutting her milk chocolate cheesecake into bite size pieces. “I post all my baking online just for fun. I entered because I thought it would be a really great way to meet people in the community.” Gelsond says she combined a bunch of different ideas to come up with her recipe. “I tested it once last weekend but I make it every year for my boyfriend’s birthday in February. We’ve been together 2-1/2 years so it must work.” Alec, standing nearby adds, “Yes, it’s the secret sauce.”
Nancy Broff, entry number 58, has made an apple-blackberry pie. “I like to bake with colored dough. It’s all natural. I’ve made this a number of times with different designs for the crust. The pie today is inspired from a quilt I saw recently when I made a visit to the National Museum of Women in the Arts.” She says it was quite a process. “I made three different pie crusts for the design. I made the dough yesterday and let it sit in the fridge overnight.”
Andrea Hamre has made a Swedish bread. “I learned to make this bread from my Swedish family when I was a Rotary exchange student in 2000. I think what makes this bread different is the high amount of milk and butter.” She says, “There is a culture in Sweden built around fresh bread. They eat this bread with butter, cheese, meat, and, of course, it is good with fondue.”
Susan Smith has made Kardemummabullar (Swedish cardamom buns). She says she made two batches ahead of time and then made another extra one yesterday which proofed overnight so she would have it baked fresh for the judges. “I chose this recipe because I have a friend in Sweden. It is good for the cold weather now, to have a cozy warm day when you have a sweet treat and coffee with a friend.”
Melanie Vinojur’s mother stands with her grandson behind her daughter’s samples of apple-almond tart. “Usually this tart would be made with pears but the kids went apple picking. We came home with a whole bunch of apples so we peeled them all and made this with apples instead.”
Amy Fuller has made her Bakery Lane Soup Bowl Apple Cake with Caramel Frosting. “I have been making this since I was a college student, a long-time ago! It’s not too complicated, just peeling the apples. I always get a request to take it at Thanksgiving.”
Library Director Diane Kresh, in disguise as Paula Hollywood, after the famous British Bake off Judge Paul Hollywood, mingles around the room chatting with the contestants and waiting to pronounce the grand “Showstopper” winner of the day.
The Great American Bake Off is part of the Library’s year long celebration of the nourishing and community building power of food. This event invited amateur bakers from the DMV area to show off their best creations and the community to taste and vote for their favorite. Each category was also considered by a judge along with the votes from the community, and the final Showstopper award was given by Paula Hollywood.
The winners were:
Showstopper: Cassandra Mattson (Black Sesame Oatmeal Cream Pies)
Pie: Kimberly Shiao (Miso Caramel Gochujang Tart)
Bread: Kristen Stevens & Shannon Mok (Sticky Gulab Jamun-Inspired Cardamom Buns)
Cake: David Inserra (Torta de Santiago)
Tray Bake: Leni Perkins (Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies)
People’s Choice: Janie Gelfond (Milk Chocolate Cheesecake)
An estimated 500 were in attendance, and when the event was over only crumbs remained at many of the tasting sites.
Other events have included author talks sponsored by the premier Public Library “Arlington Reads” program which began in February and will end in December. The Arlington Reads program turns 20 this year, and to celebrate it’s anniversary as well as the 250th anniversary of the United States, the program looked at American life, culture and history through the lens of food.
Nancy Broff with her apple-blackberry pie with designer crust
Andrea Hamre with her Swedish bread
Melanie Vinojur’s apple-almond tart

The Great American Bake Off at Central Library Nov. 14